Schedule
| Date | Time | Event |
| Sat 09/05/09 | 1:30 PM | FB: Baldwin-Wallace College |
| Sat 09/12/09 | 1:30 PM | FB: Butler University |
| Sat 09/26/09 | 1:30 PM | FB: Trine University |
| Sat 10/03/09 | 1:30 PM | FB: Defiance College* |
| Sat 10/10/09 | 1:30 PM | FB: Bluffton University* |
| Sat 10/17/09 | 1:30 PM | FB: Anderson University* (Homecoming) |
| Sat 10/24/09 | 1:30 PM | FB: College of Mount St. Joseph* |
| Sat 10/31/09 | 1:30 PM | FB: Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology* |
| Sat 11/07/09 | 1:30 PM | FB: Manchester College* |
| Sat 11/14/09 | 1:30 PM | FB: Hanover College* (Victory Bell Classic) |
| Wed 11/18/09 | 7:30 PM | MB: EARLHAM |
| Sat 11/21/09 | 3:00 PM | MB: MILLIKIN |
| Tue 11/24/09 | 8:00 PM | MB: Centre |
| Sat 11/28/09 | 8:00 PM | MB: Wabash (Mike Rokicki Tournament @ DePauw) |
| Sun 11/29/09 | 2:00 PM | MB: Washington & Jefferson (Mike Rokicki Tournament @ DePauw) |
| Wed 12/02/09 | 7:30 PM | MB: ROSE-HULMAN* (Bankers Night) |
| Mon 12/07/09 | 7:00 PM | MB: Trine (Rescheduled from Nov. 16) |
| Wed 12/09/09 | 7:30 PM | MB: TRANSYLVANIA* |
| Sat 12/12/09 | 3:00 PM | MB: Bluffton* |
| Sat 12/19/09 | 3:00 PM | MB: NORTH CENTRAL |
| Tue 12/22/09 | 8:30 PM | MB: Eastern Illinois |
| Sat 01/02/10 | 3:00 PM | MB: Wabash |
| Wed 01/06/10 | 7:30 PM | MB: Anderson* |
| Sat 01/09/10 | 4:00 PM | MB: MANCHESTER* |
| Wed 01/13/10 | 7:30 PM | MB: HANOVER* (Raymond James Rivalry Game) |
| Sat 01/16/10 | 4:00 PM | MB: Defiance* |
| Wed 01/20/10 | 7:30 PM | MB: Mount St. Joseph* |
| Wed 01/27/10 | 7:30 PM | MB: Rose-Hulman* |
| Sat 01/30/10 | 3:00 PM | MB: BLUFFTON* (Alumni Day) |
| Wed 02/03/10 | 7:30 PM | MB: Transylvania* |
| Mon 02/08/10 | 7:30 PM | MB: ANDERSON* (rescheduled from Feb. 6) |
| Wed 02/10/10 | 7:30 PM | MB: Hanover* |
| Sat 02/13/10 | 4:00 PM | MB: Manchester* |
| Wed 02/17/10 | 7:30 PM | MB: MOUNT ST. JOSEPH* |
| Sat 02/20/10 | 4:00 PM | MB: DEFIANCE* |
| Tue 02/23/10 | 8:00 PM | MB: Defiance (HCAC Tournament First Round) |
| Home | Away | Neutral Site | * HCAC |
FB: Football
MB: Men's basketball